The shouting match of RFK Jr., lawmakers over Americans' health
09/08/2025
The shouting match of RFK Jr., lawmakers over Americans’ health
The health secretary's “defiant performance at the Senate Finance Committee on Thursday, his critics say, put on vivid display what happens when someone with no medical or scientific training and a conspiracy-minded approach takes charge of the nation’s public health,” says a New York Times analysis.
“Instead of being guided by rigorous research and nuanced debate over complex issues that defy easy answers, the country’s health secretary rejects facts that do not fit his theories and casts out experts who are not aligned with him. He is buoyed by the support of a vocal populist base that shares his suspicions of organized medicine and is energized by his push for a new approach,” the Times says.
Kennedy’s distrust of his department’s scientists and doctors has created turmoil in the nation’s public health agencies, especially the CDC, says the Times. Mass firings and restructuring have stripped the CDC of expertise. The health secretary dismissed an entire panel of vaccine experts. And he fired CDC Director Susan Monarez — whom he'd called a “brilliant microbiologist and a tech wizard” — just a month after the Senate confirmed her.
At Thursday’s hearing, GOP Sens. Bill Cassidy, La., and John Barrasso, Wyo., both medical doctors, joined Democrats in criticizing Kennedy for undermining vaccines.
Here are highlights of the hearing, from PBS.
And here is a fact check, from The Associated Press.
Here is an opinion article by fired CDC Director Monarez, in The Wall Street Journal.
In recent days, Kennedy’s sister Kerry and his nephew, former Rep. Joe Kennedy III, D-Mass., have called for him to step down. And three former surgeons general, including Dr. Jerome Adams, who served during the first Trump administration, write in a USA Today essay that Kennedy is jeopardizing the integrity of the CDC and public health.
Meanwhile, as Florida takes steps to be the first state to eliminate school vaccine mandates, other states are pledging to protect vaccines for children and adults, AP reports.
Also in the news since our last chat
Democratic Republic of Congo reports new outbreak of Ebola virus
U.S. buying 2 million doses of HIV prevention drug lenacapvir for low-income countries
Iran increased its stockpile of near weapons-grade uranium before Israeli attack, UN agency says
In rare ruling, Israel Supreme Court says Israeli government deprives Palestinian prisoners of food
Judge blocks Trump administration’s ending of legal protections for 1.1 million Venezuelans, Haitians
Trump administration asks Supreme Court to let the president fire a member of Federal Trade Commission
Judge rules Trump administration’s freeze of $2.2 billion in Harvard grants was illegal
Heather Cox Richardson on Trump’s executive order renaming Department of Defense as Department of War, more
ProPublica: Trump is accusing foes with multiple mortgages of fraud; 3 of his Cabinet members have them, records show
House rejects effort to censure New Jersey Democratic Rep. LaMonica McIver over actions at detention center
Epstein survivors implore Congress to act as push for disclosure increases
D.C. lawsuit challenges Trump’s National Guard deployment; Georgia to become 7th state sending troops to D.C.
Thousands protest Trump’s deployment of National Guard in D.C. march
Thousands protest in Chicago against ICE, Trump intervention plans
California, Delaware attorneys general tell OpenAI, other tech companies to improve chatbot safety for kids, teens
Anthropic agrees to pay authors $1.5 billion to settle lawsuit by book authors over pirated copies used to train AI chatbots
Trump administration agrees to restore health websites, data in lawsuit settlement
KFF: Trump administration investigating Medicaid spending on immigrants in blue states